08/05/2007

animal thoughts

Some animals can feel and think in ways not too dissimilar from us, welfare campaigners say.
They say there is evidence of altruism, with some animals acting disinterestedly for the good of others. Animals which live in communities, they say, often exhibit signs of morality which resembles human behaviour. There is scientific backing for their claims, with huge implications for human use of animals.
The concept that animals are sentient - possessing a level of conscious awareness, and able to have feelings - was recognised by the European Union in 1997.
In a briefing paper, CIWF (compassion in world farming) says: "There is evidence that some animals do have some level of morality and some concern over other animals."
"Living within a group requires a moral code of behaviour... Most animals that live in communities exhibit similar moral codes to humans."
"Zoologists who have spent their professional lives studying animal behaviour, either by observation or by experiments to test their mental capacities, believe that many animals feel and think."
The claim of scientific backing for the concept of animal sentience has its critics, who say it is simple anthropomorphism, the projection of human traits onto animals.
Read this whole BBC article here or read the bluelight thread here.

2 comments:

  1. Such a cool post!!!!! I also believe that animals show feeling and a moral code, but the critics do have a point when they call it anthropomorphism. This critique can be ignored when you reverse the situation. This is what Frans de Waal does, he calls traits like reciprocity, empathy and conflict resolution animal from the beginning and than looks for those characteristics in us humans.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Why should our nastiness be the baggage of an apish past and our kindness uniquely human?
    Why should we not seek continuity with other animals for our “noble” traits as well?

    - Stephen Jay Gould (1980)

    ReplyDelete